Detect individual strings on a standard guitar without a HEX pickup

@kimyo, your last post merely repeats your personal opinion in this thread.

That’s why I’d like to repeat it one more time for you:

Jul 11

There’s something I don’t understand: are there limitations to having reasonable hope in the short term? Jamorigin and Migic undoubtedly work differently; Jamorigin generally works better, but Migic recognizes minor 2 a bit better. Is it possible that they’ll share criteria at a colloquium or developers’ conference and give us all a step forward, each with their own unique approach? I understand they start with the old and ever-relevant Fourier transform, then do the arduous work of classification. There’s so much previous work published, but from what I read, that approach is insurmountable. So, neural networks have nothing else to offer us guitarists besides Nam A2? I hope they don’t give up by suggesting HEX. I had my GR-300, my PG-380, I didn’t have a Sythaxe but I came close… I bought all the GR models. I’m tired of it. I see wonders in this age of AI, and yet progress in this field is so slow…

Hi @Perri, there is no apparent scientific or technical reason for insurmountable obstacles standing in the way of our hopes for the near future.

Single-string detection for MidiGuitar Standard will not only enable all hex functionalities on a standard guitar but also resolve various note recognition issues in the current MidiGuitar Standard:such as improved recognition of minor second intervals or better recognition of fifths and octaves.

MidiBass will also benefit from faster recognition rates thanks to single-string detection.

Furthermore, many string-specific control functions will then be possible thanks to the mathematically unambiguous determination of the position on the fretboard, such as fret zones for different sounds or articulation switches for strings/wind instruments, etc.

EDIT: And another major benefit: The magnetic pickups on a standard guitar sound significantly better than the thin HEX pickups—a major advantage for the further development of the GUITARMODS project by @JamO.

1 Like