Hi, I’m getting constant double notes when trying to record MIDI Guitar 3 data into Pro Tools on Mac. Everything is set pretty standard, I’m on bridge pickup, monophonic, and have very low latency - but as you can see from the screenshots I’m getting a ton of unwanted doubles coming through. Anyone else had this problem or know how to fix it? Thanks!
That does look strange, actually. Your screenshots suggest that when you lift your fingers another note is triggered until the new note is played. You can check with a MIDI monitor if releasing the fret creates a new “note on” event.
Have you tried reducing the input gain and/or using “MIDI 1.0 Legacy” instead of MPE?
Hey, thanks for replying. You’re correct that’s exactly what’s happening - I can feel it happen quite obviously in real time when playing (not every time but most times as you can see). I’ve tried switching midi modes and reducing input gain, the gate, the strike settings etc. Also happens in MG2.
i might be imagining things but i kind of remember something like this when experimenting with very low latency settings.
also - does this behavior occur outside of protools? (ie: mg3 standalone)
Hey, thanks for replying. Yes it’s happening in MG3 standalone, I can hear it simply playing a single note and then there’s an double right as my finger lifts. I’ve tried low latency at 64buffer as well as 128. Really no idea what’s happening but it’s effectively a tremolo-pick effect, which while kind of cool is not ideal ![]()
it might help if you post an audio snippet of the raw guitar.
Hi guys, I’ve done a quick screen recording to demonstrate:
YouTube Video: MG3 in Pro Tools
I’m using bridge pickup and a fretwrap and you can hear the doubles happen mostly on staccato notes, or when changing from one note to another. Weirdly I’m finding that using expressive instead of monophonic makes the doubles almost entirely disappear, but not sure why.
Off topic, but I have the scale filter set to G major in MG3, but sometimes notes outwith the scale are still creeping through in PT. Any ideas?
is your action on the low side? have you checked the intonation?
Action is low on all my guitars, intonation fine.
I use Pro Tools on a Mac with MIDI Guitar 3 with no issues with 3 different instruments (2 six string guitars and 1 5 string piccolo bass, all hex). I use the standalone version and send MIDI to my instrument and MIDI tracks in Pro Tools. I get no double notes. I have never used monophonic mode or the scale tracker. Have you tried taking out the scale tracker and switch to expressive mode to see if there is a difference? Also, what computer are you using? I have a MBP M5 Max and run MG3 at 16 samples and Pro Tools at 64 samples with no issues (except for my sloppy playing sometimes
).
To me, your input gate seems to be set extremely high. I’m not claiming this is the reason for your double-note issue, but it stuck out immediately.
When configuring MG3, start with a simple synth with a basic waveform. Different instruments have different response profiles and you want to be remove as many variables as possible.
Also, is there any possibility that you have a MIDI loop present? Again, likely not the reason but good to rule out.
I am using the non-hex version; the appeal of MIDI Guitar originally was that you aren’t supposed to need extra hardware. I do get fewer double notes on expressive mode but don’t know why. I am on a Mac Mini M4 Pro, running both MG3 and PT at 64 samples.
Thanks for your reply. I do really appreciate everyone commenting trying to help!
I’ve been playing around with the gate in case it could filter whatever was causing double notes. Not sure what changing the instrument would do - the MIDI data being sent to PT is the same regardless. I could have no instrument loaded at all and the data coming in would be the same, no?
Not sure what you mean by a MIDI loop, could you be more specific?
What is your interface? And have you tried recording just midi? I have rarely ever recorded midi and audio at the same time but will look at that today. As far as your gate and input settings go, mine are pretty close to the same and I have not seen any issues. I will also try non hex to see if there is a difference as well. I have been using MG3 as my main midi controller for over 2 years with none of the issues you are having. Hopefully you can get this figured out.
Gil
Scarlett 18i20. Yes I’d usually just record the MIDI on it’s own (same issue there though), but somebody higher up asked for the raw guitar audio too. Thank you.
I just tried regular MG3 with monophonic. No issues. I put the scale filter on and started getting false notes. Try taking that off and see if you get better performance.
when i run your raw audio thru mg3 i get this: (guitar left, synth right)
@digimidi is probably onto the culprit.
Interesting, can you screenshot your settings please? Note filter on/off doesn’t seem to be making any difference to me (on monophonic - expressive it’s actually working decently enough so I guess I’ll stick with that).
Use a simple instrument to remove variables potentially introduced by a more complex instrument to focus the issue and more effectively solve your problem.
The same applies to anything in the processing chain. See @digimidi’s suggestion on the Scale Filter module. Try removing/bypassing it.
The hypothetical MIDI loop I refered to is where MIDI from the output gets delivered back to the input, thus creating a loop. Some DAWs make it very easy to accidentally do this. But, I don’t think this is your problem. Just double notes made me think of it.




