Hello,
I’m a long time MIDI guitar player, and I’ve used a number of older solutions in the past. I’m still using a Roland GR-55 and also an Axon 100 mkII coupled with a Roland Integra 7 (almost all my guitars are Godin with GK compatible outputs).
I’m evaluating the demo version to figure out if it’s a viable solution to replace my Axon. This means that I’m not interested in onboard sounds or effects; only in the tracking quality and the flexibility of MIDI communication with external devices.
I have a couple of remarks / questions already.
-
So far, I’m quite impressed with the tracking speed and quality, especially given the fact that only the normal guitar output is used. It is also very convenient that you don’t need a long setup phase for all the guitars you use (I use at least 6 different guitars with MIDI). I have a couple of problems with polyphonic tracking though.
-
When I play chords with 4 or 5 notes at the same time (especially with a pick), the tracking seems less accurate. In particular, I often seem get 3 notes only, or notes with a very low volume compared to the others. Are there any known issues in that regard, or do I need to know anything about the influence of picking technique?
-
Some chords are not recognized correctly, which is a showstopper. For example, if I play a Gsus4 (G F A C), the low G is turned into an F. This is very audible when I play the low G first, and then the other 3 notes simultaneously. I’ve read about similar problems supposedly fixed in the payed versions. Would that apply here?
-
I’ve never used the string-based split functions of the Axon or the various Roland products, so I don’t mind ditching hexaphonic pickups (on the contrary). String-based sensitivity setting could be a problem, but maybe the GM2’s algorithm is smart enough to not require this anymore. However, it seems that the GM2’s MIDI output is not really configurable, which would be a problem. Is it possible to customize the output channel(s) for Note on/off messages? Is is possible to filter out “ghost” notes? etc.
-
Final question: my several guitars may require different adjustments, notably the input gain. Are the interface modules (audio and midi) stored in patches as well as the rest?
Oh, and a final note: out of curiosity (and hope) I have tried GM2 with an electric sitar. The result is disappointing, although not surprising (given the amount of transitory “noise” in a sitar sound). It works more or less in monophonic mode, but it is a disaster with chords. Would there be any interest in working on this? I have not tried my sitar with the Axon yet, as I need to install a GK3 on it first
That’s it. Thanks for your time!